Proplytics vs a spreadsheet for tracking prop firm costs and payouts
In short. A spreadsheet can track prop firm challenge fees, resets, activations and payouts, and for a lot of traders it should stay the tool. Proplytics runs the same subtraction in an iPhone and Android app, keeps the ledger on your account, and draws the equity curve from what you type. Keep the sheet if you update it. Use the app if the file has gone stale.
I'm the founder of Proplytics. I compete with some of the options on this page. I link to their pages and I say when they are the better fit. Corrections go to info@selmissconsulting.nl.
A cost ledger for prop firm accounts is a short list of money in and money out. A spreadsheet has been able to hold that list for as long as spreadsheets have existed. I would still tell plenty of traders to keep the file they already have.
What the sheet is for
Prop firm dashboards are built around the payout. The challenge fee, the reset and the activation sit on a card statement in another app. The figure that belongs in your own books is the payouts minus those costs.
A trading journal stores the trades you place inside an account. A cost sheet stores what the account cost to attempt and what it paid you when a withdrawal cleared. You can keep both. A lot of people only need the second one, and a grid of rows will hold it.
Start with date, firm, account, type and amount. Types: challenge, reset, activation, payout, plus a data or platform fee if you want that fee in the number. The subtraction, with a labelled example, is in the net P&L post.
What a spreadsheet does well
The useful version of this file costs nothing extra if you already have Google Sheets, Excel or LibreOffice. You own it. You can add a column the month a firm invents a new fee name, sort by firm, filter to one account size, and send the file to an accountant without waiting on someone else's export. A copy in a folder you already back up is a real backup. Desktop sheets work on a train with no signal.
Cammy Capital's Prop Tracker, in a Substack post on 3 January 2026, is a free download that logs eval fees, resets, rebills, activation fees and payouts, then calculates net PnL. I re-read that post on 17 October 2026 and did not audit the formulas. It is a public example of the same subtraction. You can do it without buying software from me.
I would stay with a sheet when these are true together:
- You buy challenges from one firm, or two at most.
- A fee hits a few times a month, and you open the file the same day.
- You want the raw rows in a format you can sort, annotate and back up yourself.
- You will build a cumulative chart, or you are content with a single total.
- You would rather pay nothing than pay a subscription to be reminded.
If that is already how you work, keep the sheet. A subscription on top of a habit you keep is another fee.
Where the file goes quiet
The usual miss is dull. You pass on a Tuesday. The activation posts on Wednesday. The sheet still ends last month, because you were in a trade and the weekend felt soon enough. By Sunday the receipt is one notification among forty, and the row never gets typed. The total is then a tidy number with a hole in it. A blank cell you know is blank is easier to trust than a finished-looking total that dropped a fee.
Formulas slip too. A SUM that was right for twelve rows points at the wrong range after you insert a line above the totals, or after a new firm gets its own tab and never joins the summary. Firms also use different words for the same cash. One charge is a reset, another is a rebill, and a third firm has stopped selling resets, so you buy a new evaluation. A filter on the word "reset" drops two of those lines.
The phone version of a sheet is the same grid, drawn small, and the laptop is often shut in the two minutes after you pay, which is when you still know which account the charge belongs to. A cumulative chart is buildable and then easy to abandon. The sheets I kept had a total I trusted on good weeks and a chart I had stopped opening. The record depends on a file you have to remember to touch.
What Proplytics covers, and what it leaves alone
Proplytics is that ledger on iPhone and Android. You type the firm, the account size, the phase and an amount: challenge fee, reset, activation or payout. From those rows it shows net P&L, ROI on spend, a cumulative equity curve, win rate and average cost per challenge, with a per-firm split. The ledger sits on your account and syncs between devices. Sign-in is email. There is no prop firm password and no broker login, so a locked firm dashboard does not block the record.
The price on the site and in the stores is $4.99 a month or $44.99 a year, billed by Apple or Google. You cancel in that store. The site describes the yearly plan as 25% less than paying monthly, which works out at $3.75 a month.
You still type every fee and every payout. A payout you skip stays off the books, the same as a row missing from a sheet. There is no trade log, no replay and no bank import. The homepage figure of +$4,410 and +203% ROI is an example I made up so the layout is visible. It is not a customer result.
Some journals keep a fee ledger beside the trades. TradeZella is the one I compared separately, because it does both jobs at a journal price. If you already pay for a tool that holds the fees honestly, a third place to type the same activation is optional.
How I would choose this week
Open the file, or a blank one. Can you see the same numbers on your phone if the laptop stays home? Can you see the weeks where fees ran ahead of payouts without rebuilding a chart? If you add a firm today, does the grand total include it without a formula edit?
Yes means the sheet is doing the job. Keep it. If the file has become its own project, the app is the copy I use so the number is on the phone the day the charge happens. The arithmetic is in the net P&L guide, with a labelled example, so you can check a total on paper first.
A blank Google Sheet is cheaper than $4.99. The subscription pays for the phone app, the account that follows a new device, and charts tied to the rows you type. When the rows are few and you actually update them, the sheet is the better tool.
Questions
Is a spreadsheet enough to track prop firm costs?
Yes, if you update it when you pay. Date, firm, account, type and amount are enough to reach the same net as an app. The formula post walks through a labelled example.
What does Proplytics add on top of a spreadsheet?
An iOS and Android app, a ledger that follows your account to a new phone, and net P&L, ROI, an equity curve, win rate and average cost per challenge from the rows you type. There is no bank or broker import.
Can Proplytics import my spreadsheet?
No. You type challenge fees, resets, activations and payouts yourself, including older ones.
How much does Proplytics cost compared with a sheet?
$4.99 per month or $44.99 per year, billed by the App Store or Google Play. A sheet costs whatever Google Sheets, Excel or LibreOffice already costs you.
Example numbers on this site, including the homepage ledger, are examples. They are not customer results.