How to calculate your real net P&L on prop firm accounts (fees, resets, payouts)
In short. Add every payout that actually arrived. Subtract challenge fees, reset or rebill fees, activation fees, and any data or platform fee you have decided to count. That difference is your net P&L for the funding chase. ROI is the net divided by the costs. The numbers further down are an example I invented so the arithmetic can be checked.
The payout email and the card statement answer different questions. One is what the firm sent. The other is what the accounts cost. Net P&L for a prop firm chase is the second number taken off the first, with a few timing rules so the total stays tied to cash.
I publish Proplytics, which runs this arithmetic on rows you type. A notebook runs it too. The rules are the same.
The formula
Keep one line, and keep the categories stable from month to month.
Net P&L = payouts − (challenge fees + reset fees + activation fees + other account costs you choose to include). ROI on spend = net P&L ÷ total costs.
Use receipt amounts and payout confirmations, in one currency. If a firm charges in euros and pays you in dollars, convert each line on the day it happened and note the rate. A mixed-currency column looks precise and is not.
Count a cost on the day you paid it. If a fee is refunded later, log the refund as money in on the day it lands. Until then the fee is still a cost. Booking a refund you have only been promised is how a red month becomes a green cell.
What goes in each bucket
Challenge fees are the price of an evaluation, a combine, or a new attempt when a firm makes you buy again. The second and third purchases count. A failed challenge is a finished expense.
Reset fees restart the same evaluation. A rebill is the same kind of cash under another label. Keep the line, and use a name you will recognise later.
Activation fees are what some firms charge when you pass and they open the funded account. They land on a good day, next to a congratulations email, and they are still costs.
Other account costs are a data fee or a platform fee, if you want them in this number. Use one rule for every firm. Leave home internet, the monitor and lunch for an accountant. That is a different question from what the accounts returned.
Payouts are money the firm sent that has arrived. Simulator profit is a rule you met, and a withdrawal you requested this morning is still pending. Log the amount that clears.
Trades stay out. A green Tuesday inside a challenge you lost on Wednesday did not pay you. The account cost a fee, or it sent a payout. A journal reviews the trades. This number treats the account as a purchase.
A worked example
Everything in this section is made up. I picked round figures so you can re-add them on a calculator. They are not a typical result, not an average, and not anyone's account. If you quote them, call them an example.
One quarter, two firms, one currency.
Costs paid:
| Item | Amount |
|---|---|
| Challenge, Firm A | $400 |
| Reset, Firm A | $150 |
| Second challenge, Firm A, after the reset also failed | $400 |
| Activation, Firm A, once that second attempt passed | $150 |
| Challenge, Firm B | $200 |
| Platform fee included for Firm B | $30 |
Total costs = 400 + 150 + 400 + 150 + 200 + 30 = $1,330.
Payouts that arrived:
| Item | Amount |
|---|---|
| Firm A, first payout | $1,500 |
| Firm A, second payout | $600 |
Total payouts = 1,500 + 600 = $2,100.
Net P&L = 2,100 − 1,330 = $770.
ROI on spend = 770 ÷ 1,330, about 57.9%.
A page that only lists transfers shows +$2,100. The net in this example is $770. Both can be calculated from the same quarter. $2,100 is what the firm transferred. $770 is what was left after the accounts were bought.
The failed first challenge and the failed reset stay in the cost. Dropping that $550 would print a net of $1,320, which describes a trader who never paid for the attempts that missed.
Firm B contributed costs and no payout. It still belongs in the all-firm number. A per-firm view is useful, and the single total includes the firm that paid nothing.
The $30 platform fee is optional. Remove it and the costs are $1,300, the net is $800, and the ROI is 800 ÷ 1,300, about 61.5%. Write the rule down so the next quarter uses the same boundary.
Average cost per challenge, counting two Firm A attempts and one Firm B attempt, is 1,330 ÷ 3, about $443. That average folds a reset and an activation into "per challenge," so treat it as a blunt planning figure. Cost per payout here is 1,330 ÷ 2 = $665 behind each transfer that arrived.
Split by firm, then add it back
Firm A costs 400 + 150 + 400 + 150 = $1,100. Payouts are $2,100. Net is $1,000. ROI is 1,000 ÷ 1,100, about 90.9%.
Firm B costs 200 + 30 = $230. Payouts are $0. Net is −$230.
All-firm net is 1,000 + (−230) = $770, the same answer as the single formula. When the two routes disagree, a line is in the wrong bucket or it was counted twice.
One more invented case: a $300 challenge and a $300 reset, with no payout, net −$600. That quarter is on the card statement. A payout page never shows it.
What the number leaves alone
It will not tell you whether the next challenge pays. One payout can cover a stack of attempts, and the attempts can resume on Monday. A negative quarter can be one pass away from a withdrawal, or a stretch of buying challenges in place of trading them. The ledger keeps the payout email from standing in for the card statement, and it stops there.
This is not tax advice. Keep the receipts and ask an accountant before you file. Firm price lists also move, so copy the amount from your own receipt. One reset is a monthly subscription, another is a one-time charge, and some firms have stopped selling resets, so you buy a new evaluation. The bucket is the cash you paid to keep an attempt alive.
A sheet, or the app
Five columns are enough: date, firm, account, type, amount. Costs and payouts can sit in separate columns, or costs can be negative and payouts positive under one sum. The spreadsheet post is about when that file is the better tool, including the weeks it falls behind.
Proplytics stores the same events on iOS and Android. The running net, the ROI and an equity curve come from what you enter. The price is $4.99 a month or $44.99 a year on the App Store and Google Play. The app does not read fees from your bank. You type them. That is the whole method.
Questions
Does a payout I requested, but have not received, count?
Count it on the day the money arrives. A pending withdrawal stays off the total.
Do I include a challenge I failed?
Yes. The fee left your card. Dropping failed attempts inflates the net.
Should simulated profit inside a challenge count as a payout?
No. Log a payout when a withdrawal clears, not when a simulator shows a profit.
What if the firm refunds the fee later?
Keep the fee as a cost on the day you paid. Log the refund as money in on the day it arrives.
Example numbers on this site, including the homepage ledger, are examples. They are not customer results.